The National Institute of Health Research and Development of the Ministry of
Health has carried out a field study to measure the prices and availability of
medicines using the WHO/HAI price measurement methodology. Data on the prices and availability of 42 medicines were collected in the public, private for-profit and other sectors in
six provinces.
The study took place in one municipality and one district in each selected
province. The cost of treatment was calculated for 12 treatments and compared to
the daily wage of the lowest paid unskilled government worker. The price
analysis was limited to 33 medicines, while the other 9 medicines are to be
analysed separately as a component of TRIPs study.
The results show that in Indonesia, the prices of medicines are high and with
small variation between public and private sector and between regions. In
general, the prices of the innovator brand products were much higher than
international reference prices; on average they were more than 20 times higher.
They were also about 2-7 times higher than the most sold generic equivalents
and, in some cases, more than 10-15 times higher. The lowest price generic
equivalents were also expensive. In public procurement for primary healthcare
prices of generics were found to be on average 74% higher than the international
procurement prices. The patient prices in public hospital pharmacies and in
private for-profit sector (private retail pharmacies and private hospitals) are
almost identical.
Affordability analysis showed that treatment of diabetes with innovator brand
glibenclamide from a private pharmacy would require 8.4 days’ wages to pay for a
month’s supply. In contrast, treating diabetes with generic glibenclamide is
less than tenfold as expensive, requiring 0.6 days’ wages in both public and
private pharmacies. A week’s treatment for pneumonia would require 1.5 days
salary to pay for innovator brand amoxicillin, 0.4 days for a generic.
The principal conclusions of the study are as follows: Prices are high
compared to international reference prices in public and private pharmacies and there are large differences between innovator brand and generic equivalent products. The prices of generic medicines vary and the cheapest
generic equivalent is not always the most sold. The availability of medicines in public sector, especially in
public procurement, is far from optimal. This could be due to a restricted list being used in public sector
and not corresponding well with the list of medicines surveyed. The price difference
between what patients pay in public and private sectors are small. Generics are
widely available in all sectors and the prices are much lower than innovator
brand products making treatment more affordable for most people but we do not
know whether they are being promoted and sold as often as they should. The
prices vary little across regions in Indonesia and suggests that distribution
and transportation cost have little influence on final price. Indonesian public
health sector is inefficient in procurement as prices obtained are on average almost two times the international procurement prices.