The indicator values in Table 6 reflect the areas of work of countries and all sectors working to achieve the objectives of pharmaceutical policies and programmes. They do not give the whole picture, but nevertheless provide important information for reviewing the performance of governments and others, and in assessing improvements (or otherwise) within a country's pharmaceutical sector.
Most of the 26 country progress indicators use data obtained from the World Drug Situation 1999 survey and the WHO database of pharmaceutical country information as their baseline. Target values for 2003 have been set as expected progress for each target outcome. These values will be used as a reference point when identifying country pharmaceutical strategies and activities to be promoted and supported.
Most of the country progress indicator values simply indicate whether a country has certain structures and mechanisms in place (yes/no), and has established certain procedures (yes/no). For some country progress indicators, data have been grouped and classified by range of percentage (for example, percentage of population with access to essential drugs) and according to date of updating (for example, a national drug policy updated within the last 10 years).
Several variables have been grouped together as the minimum criteria necessary for ensuring implementation of a particular component of a pharmaceutical strategy or plan. These composite indicators based on several variables are clearly more robust than indicators based on a single variable. The indicators with composite variables are:
Table 6 Country progress indicators for components of WHO Medicines Strategy 2000 - 2003
|
Components and Numbered Country Progress Indicators |
Indicator type |
1999 status |
2003 target |
|
|
|
No./No. reporting |
% |
|
Component 1: Implementation and monitoring of national drug policies |
1. |
Countries with an official national drug policy document new or updated within the last 10 years |
S |
66/151 |
44% |
55% |
2. |
Countries with a national drug policy implementation plan new or updated within the last 5 years |
S |
39/107 |
36% |
43% |
Component 2: Health system development supported by essential drugs policies and programmes |
|
|
|
|
3. |
Countries with a national drug policy included in the national health plan |
S |
n.a.* |
n.a. |
n.a. |
4. |
Countries with a national policy on traditional medicine |
S |
31/46 |
n.a. |
n.a. |
Component 3: Access strategy and monitoring for essential drugs |
|
|
|
|
5. |
Countries where less than 50% of the population has access to essential drugs |
0 |
30/187 |
16% |
14% |
6. |
% of key drugs available in health facilities (measured in countries with comprehensive programmes) |
0 |
n.a.* |
n.a. |
80% |
Component 4: Financing mechanisms and affordability of essential drugs |
|
|
|
|
7. |
Countries with public drug expenditure per capita of less than U$2.00 |
P |
39/94 |
41% |
35% |
8. |
Countries with generic substitution allowed in private pharmacies |
P |
83/134 |
61% |
75% |
9. |
Countries with public health insurance covering drug costs |
S + P |
71/111 |
64% |
70% |
Component 5: National and local public sector drug supply systems and supply capacity |
|
|
|
|
10. |
Countries with public sector procurement based on a national list of essential drugs |
P |
70/132 |
53% |
60% |
11. |
Countries with at least 75% of public sector procurement carried out by competitive tender |
P |
79/88 |
90% |
95% |
12. |
Countries implementing the 1999 interagency guidelines on drug donations |
P |
n.a.* |
n.a. |
80% |
Component 6: Norms, standards and guidance for pharmaceuticals |
|
|
|
|
13. |
Countries participating in the WHO Certification Scheme on the Quality of Pharmaceutical Products Moving in International Commerce |
P |
142/191 |
74% |
80% |
Component 7: Drug regulation and quality assurance systems |
|
|
|
|
14. |
Countries operating basic drug regulatory system (key legislation and drug regulatory authority functions) |
S + P |
92/135 |
68% |
75% |
15. |
Countries with basic quality assurance procedures (good manufacturing practices and sampling to test drugs) |
S + P |
87/139 |
62% |
75% |
16. |
Countries with laws and regulations covering herbal medicines |
S |
48/60 |
n.a. |
n.a. |
Component 8: Information support for pharmaceutical regulation |
|
|
|
|
17. |
Countries with computerized drug registration |
S |
n.a.* |
n.a. |
n.a. |
18. |
Countries with adverse drug monitoring/registration system |
S |
56/191 |
29%. |
35% |
Component 9: Guidance for control and use of psychotropics and narcotics |
|
|
|
|
19. |
Number of substances reviewed and recommended for classification for international control |
n.a. |
2/3** |
66% |
83% |
Component 10: Rational drug use strategy and monitoring |
|
|
|
|
20. |
Countries with basic system (including legislation) for regulating pharmaceutical promotion |
S + P |
58/142 |
41% |
50% |
21. |
Countries with national drug information centre able to provide independent drug information to prescribers and/or dispensers |
S + P |
57/136 |
42% |
50% |
Component 11: Rational drug use by health professionals |
|
|
|
|
22. |
Countries with treatment guidelines updated within the last 5 years |
S |
55/86 |
64% |
70% |
23. |
Countries with national list of essential drugs updated within the last 5 years |
S |
127/175 |
73% |
75% |
24. |
Countries that include the concept of essential drugs in basic curricula for medicine and/or pharmacy |
P |
88/100 |
88% |
90% |
Component 12: Rational drug use by consumers |
|
|
|
|
25. |
Countries with public education on rational drug use |
P |
n.a.* |
n.a. |
n.a. |
26. |
Countries with drug information centre/service accessible to consumers |
S + P |
n.a.* |
n.a. |
n.a. |
Key:
S country progress indicator that provides information on structure
P country progress indicator that provides information on process
O country progress indicator that provides information on outcome
S + P composite country progress indicator that provides information on both structure and process
* data will be collected in 2000 and the 2003 target set
** i.e. UNDCP accepted two out of three of WHO’s recommendations concerning substances for international control
Country progress indicator no. 9 Countries with public health insurance covering drug costs meaning that: not only does a public health insurance system exist but that it reimburses patients' drug costs.
“Evaluation is different from monitoring. The word is derived from value... Evaluation involves taking a step back to look at the program as a whole, to assess progress toward achieving goals by fulfilling objectives.”
Management Sciences for Health/World Health Organization, 1997. 50
Country progress indicator no. 14 Countries operating basic drug regulatory system including: a law on drug registration; a law on drug manufacturing or importation of drugs; inspection of either retail outlets or manufacturers; drug registration by the drug regulatory authority; a drug registration list.
Country progress indicator no. 15 Countries with basic quality assurance procedures including: request for proof of good manufacturing practices when an application for drug registration is made; either sampling of drugs for public procurement or sampling of drugs at retail outlets; drug quality testing.
Country progress indicator no. 20 Countries with basic system (including legislation) for regulating pharmaceutical promotion including: law on drug promotion which was established less than 10 years ago; regulation of drug promotion by the government or co-regulation of drug promotion by the government and the pharmaceutical industry; regulation of drug advertisements.
Country progress indicator no. 21 Countries with drug information centre able to provide independent information to prescribers and/or dispensers meaning that: not only does such a centre exist but that it actively provides information as requested by prescribers and/or dispensers.
Country progress indicator no. 26 Countries with drug information/service accessible to consumers meaning that: not only does such a centre exist but that it actively provides information as requested by consumers.
During implementation of the Medicines Strategy 2000 - 2003, the criteria for composite indicators will be refined further, and additional composite indicators identified.