Recognizing the close link between good governance and health system
strengthening, Rwanda has launched several initiatives to strengthen health
governance to date. Government- and nongovernmental organization (NGO)-led
programs have been implemented to strengthen the interactions between citizens,
health providers, and government agencies. These initiatives range from the
Government of Rwanda's (GoR) ambitious and comprehensive decentralization
reform to move decision making concerning policy implementation closer to the
population, to the use of citizen score cards to make service deliverers more
responsive to users. Benchmarking progress made through these reforms, as well
as identifying and addressing existing challenges, is essential if Rwanda is to
sustain this momentum and further improve health governance in the country. To
this end, the Rwandan Ministry of Health (MINISANTE) identified the need for an
independent review of the state of health governance in Rwanda. The U.S. Agency
for International Development in Rwanda (USAID/Rwanda) convened a team of
international and local consultants through the USAID-funded Health Systems
20/20 project to design and implement a health governance assessment. This
report presents the team's findings. The goals of the assessment were to
document successes, identify persisting challenges, and recommend ways by which
health governance in Rwanda could be further strengthened. The report provides
an indepth analysis of five themes broken down into two analytic areas:
(1) Governance Analysis of the Rwandan Health System; Processes for health
policy and law formulation; Decentralization of policy implementation; Citizen
participation in health policy decisions and service delivery.
Although it is possible to discuss separately issues of policy formulation,
health system decentralization, and citizen participation in health on a
conceptual level, it is difficult to separate these issues on a practical level.
Thus, although we provide individual discussions of the three areas, it should
be clear that the conceptual framework of co-governance that we have used in our
analysis treats these governance issues as integral components of a holistic
health system.
(2) Application of a Governance Optic to Ongoing Institutional Reforms;
Creation of the Rwanda Biomedical Center (RBC); Reformation of the
pharmaceutical supply and management system.
As a subset of the broader governance assessment, the team was asked to review
and recommend steps to improve the functioning of the newly created RBC and
propose reforms related to the Rwandan pharmaceutical system with a special
focus on the Centrale d'Achats des Medicaments Essentiels du Rwanda (CAMERWA),
the central medical store of Rwanda. Since CAMERWA will become part of the new
RBC, the subanalysis will specifically examine the governance arrangements
between the two entities and, more generally, the application of good governance
practices to the new institution and procurement process...