Current status and future challenges from clinical, regulatory, intellectual property and production perspectives
Salle A, WHO/HQ, Geneva 15-17 December 2003
Monday 15 December
09h00-09h30 |
Opening session |
| |
|
09h30-13h00 |
Experiences with Fixed-dose Combinations |
Objective |
This session provides an overview of experiences with the use of FDC products for the treatment of TB, malaria and AIDS. The different papers and presentations highlight the issues related to selection, production, quality assurance, bioavailablity and stability. The issues of field research on packaging and co-blistering will provide practical examples of attempts to address this delivery problem |
09h30-10h00 |
Fixed-dose combinations for tuberculosis: lessons learned from a clinical, production and regulatory perspective (R. Panchagnula) Comments/Feedback Bernard Fourie to comment |
10h00-10h30 |
Fixed-dose combinations for malaria: translating clinical recommendations to product supply (Peter Olumese and Andrea Bosman) Comments/Feedback Clive Ondari to comment |
10h30-11h00 |
Discussions |
11h00-11h30 |
Coffee break |
11h30-12h00 |
Fixed-dose combinations for HIV/AIDS: the pros and cons of experiences to date (Sanjay Pujari) Comments/Feedback Joep Lange to comment |
12h00-12h30 |
Analysis of the impact of introduction on Fixed-dose combinations on supply management and security when compared with separate dispensing and/or co-blistering (Jane Masiga) Comments/Feedback Cécile Macé to comment on field experiences with FDCs and co-blistered products |
12h30-13h00 |
Discussion |
13h00-14h00 |
Lunch |
14h00-17h15 |
Public Health Needs for Fixed-dose Combinations |
Objective |
This session reviews the evidence available related to the value of FDC’s in improving compliance and outcomes as well as the effect on the emergence of antimicrobial resistance. |
14h00-14h30 |
Review of the evidence on better compliance and treatment outcomes with Fixed-dose combinations when compared with separate dispensing and/or co-blistering (Jennie Connor) Feedback/experience |
14h30-15h00 |
Review of the evidence on effect of fixed-dose combinations on the development of clinical resistance when compared with separate dispensing and/or co - blistering (Warren Kaplan) David Lee to comment on both papers |
15h00-15h30 |
Discussion |
15h30-15h45 |
Tea break |
15h45-16h15 |
Field research on packaging, co-blistering; and experiences with other combinations (Jane Kengeya Kayondo) David Hoos to comment on the use of co-blistering for the MTCT+ program |
16h15-16h45 |
Comparison of the product cost of Fixed-dose combinations in comparison with separate dispensing and/or co-blistering (Robert Bwire) Comments/Feedback Yolanda Tayler to comment on cost and FDC procurement issues Harvey Bale to comment on effect of tariffs and taxes on drug costs |
16h45-17h15 |
Discussion |
18h00 |
Reception/Cocktail |
Tuesday 16 December
09h00-13h00 |
Public Health Priorities |
Objective |
These three presentations in the morning are designed to lay out the issues and experiences relating to the production, procurement, quality assurance and use of ARV FDCs. |
09h00-09h30 |
Preferred fixed-dose combinations of ARVs for first line use in HIV/AIDS (Joseph Perriens/Marco Vitoria) Comments/Feedback |
09h30-09h45 |
Clinical perspective from the field on dosing flexibility (Joep Lange) |
09h45-10h00 |
Clients perspective on Fixed-dose combinations versus dosing flexibility |
10h00-11h00 |
Discussion Bernard Pécoul to comment |
11h00-11h30 |
Coffee break |
Objective |
This session will highlight the experiences faced in bringing FDC anti malarials to the stage of them being widely supported and promoted. The process which was used of undertaking clinical trials to demonstrate efficacy and additionality will be presented. The lessons learned about dealing with regulatory hurdles will be highlighted. |
11h30-12h00 |
Additional fixed-dose combinations for malaria (Piero Olliaro and Robert Taylor) Comments/Feedback Andrea Bosman and Tom Kanyok to comment |
12h00-13h00 |
Discussion |
13h00-14h00 |
Lunch |
14h00-17h00 |
Intellectual Property Rights and Legal Options |
Objective |
This session will address the legal and practical issues around patent barriers. The first paper and discussion will focus on the issues, the definitions and the options. The discussion will allow different perspectives to be expressed. The second part of this session will be an opportunity for members of industry to present the key results of the meeting held the previous Friday in Washington DC. |
14h00-14h30 |
Legal options for overcoming patent barriers of fixed-dose combinations (Warren Kaplan) |
14h30-15h00 |
Discussion led by Richard Wilder Ellen t Hoen and Cecilia Oh to comment Cynthia Cannady (WIPO) to comment |
15h00-15h45 |
Summary of Gates Foundation sponsored meeting on FDCs held in Washington DC December 12th 2003 Panel Presentation and Discussion |
15h45-16h00 |
Tea break |
Objective |
These two sessions will focus on country experiences around the procurement of ARVs particularly FDC ARVs and also issues around TB FDCs. This will be done from the perspective of the major UN Pharmaceutical supplier and a major NGO responsible for both TB and AIDS treatment programmes. |
16h00-16h15 |
Country level experience (Hanne Bak Pedersen) |
16h15-16h30 |
MSF’s experience in procuring ARVs. Lessons from the field (Bernard Pécoul) |
16h30-17h00 |
Discussion |
Wednesday 17 December
09h00-13h00 |
Pharmaceutical Development and Quality Assurance and Regulatory Requirements |
Objective |
The sessions for the morning will all address the issues around formulation and registration and regulation of FDCs. The first presentation will outline the range of issues to be addressed in planning to produce an FDC product. The next session will report on practical experiences gained in producing FDCs from the perspective of a manufacturer. Issues around prequalification assessments will be presented by a regulator closely involved in this process. Thorny issues around when clinical trials are needed to validate FDCs and which comparators should be used for assessing bio availability will be addressed. |
09h00-09h30 |
Development of Fixed-dose combinations; pharmaceutical considerations (Susan Walters) |
09h30-09h50 |
Product formulation of Fixed-dose combinations; practical experiences (Vinod Arora) |
09h50-10h30 |
Discussion |
10h30-11h00 |
Coffee break |
11h00-11h30 |
Assessment Experiences with fixed-dose combinations (ARVs and Tuberculosis) (János Pogány) |
11h30-11h50 |
When are new clinical trials needed? (Leonard Sachs) |
11h50-12h10 |
What comparator products should be used for bioequivalence? (Roger Williams) |
12h10-13h00 |
Discussion Jérôme Barré to comment |
13h00-14h00 |
Lunch |
14h00-17h00 |
General Discussions |
Objective |
The afternoon session will be devoted to synthesizing what has been covered in the meeting, identifying areas of clear agreement, areas of dispute that could be investigated further and areas where further work is needed to clarify the issues. After the tea break a session will be held for WHO staff to agree on conclusions and recommendations for WHO actions. |
14h00-15h30 |
Discussion by all participants Overview of main observations and recommendations for each of the main subject areas |
15h30-16h00 |
Tea break |
16h00-17h00 |
Conclusions and recommendations for WHO actions Note: This final session will be WHO staff members only. Identification of next steps (action points, research priorities, etc.) facilitated by Robert Ridley |