Guide to Drug Financing Mechanisms
(1998; 64 pages) [French] [Spanish]
Table of Contents
View the documentForeword
View the documentAcknowledgements
Open this folder and view contentsIntroduction
Open this folder and view contentsChapter 1. Selection
Close this folderChapter 2. Procurement
Open this folder and view contentsObjective of procurement
Close this folderProcurement strategies
View the documentBlind confidence
View the documentSystematic distrust
View the documentCooperation
View the documentConstraints on procurement strategies
Open this folder and view contentsOrganization and structures
View the documentProcurement: important points
Open this folder and view contentsChapter 3. Distribution
Open this folder and view contentsChapter 4. Prescribing
Open this folder and view contentsSummary: contributions and limitations of the economic approach
View the documentReferences
View the documentSelected WHO publications of related interest
View the documentBack cover
 

Systematic distrust

A strategy of systematic distrust may be followed when contracts are awarded and may also apply to tenders and to transactions by mutual agreement. In the strategy of systematic distrust, the buyer trusts no particular producers or suppliers. Every purchase is made strictly as a function of the best price and quality available at the time. Neither past nor possible future transactions are considered. National producers are not favoured, and the supplier’s reputation is not considered. All that matters is the conditions that are offered for the transaction. As a result, economic relations are very unstable and opportunistic.

In awarding contracts, the only criterion for choice is price (provided the conditions of the contract are met). In open tendering, the decision will depend on several criteria, such as price and deadlines. In transactions by mutual agreement, the buyer consults various suppliers and makes a decision without necessarily stating any criteria. In all of these cases opportunistic decisions may be made.

Table 6 compares prices paid for drugs procured by two strategies, blind confidence (direct purchase) and systematic distrust (tender).

The strategy of systematic distrust has one major disadvantage the transaction costs are very high. These costs arise from the continual quest for the best price and the continual need to verify the quality of the drugs. Thus, launching invitations to tender, awarding contracts and tenders, and reaching mutual agreements require much work. They depend on strong and reliable negotiators who know the international market.

Because of the continual change of suppliers selected solely on the basis of price, there is a very high risk of acquiring less expensive drugs that do not meet quality standards. It is necessary to control the quality of almost every batch of drugs, which is very onerous and adds considerably to the transaction costs. These costs can be reduced by awarding contracts that extend for several years. The longer their duration, however, the further such contracts depart from the strategy of systematic distrust. This strategy is also risky if a batch of drugs must be rejected and a further delivery cannot be made for some time.

Table 6. Prices paid by Mali People’s Pharmacy for drugs procured by international tender and direct purchase

Drug

Price

Price ratio:
Direct/tender

 

Direct purchase

Tender

 

Aminophylline

240 mg/10 ml

50.00

13.10

3.8

Ampicillin

500 mg tablets

35.60

19.79

1.8

Griseofulvin

500 mg tablets

50.00

18.86

2.7

Praziquantel

600 mg tablets

538.00

201.17

2.7

Cotrimoxazole

80/40 tablets

32.00

7.67

4.2

Folic acid/iron

1/200 mg

21.00

4.72

4.4

Diazepam

10 mg tablets

16.00

2.85

5.6

Indometacin

25 mg tablets

25.00

3.50

7.1

Metronidazole

250 mg tablets

35.00

4.70

7.4

Paracetamol

500 mg tablets

23.00

3.12

7.4

Furosemide

40 mg tablets

28.00

3.46

8.1

Gentamicin

40 mg injection

355.00

34.42

10.3

Niclosamide

500 mg tablets

23.00

13.42

1.7

Mebendazole

500 mg tablets

282.00

16.26

17.3

Source: Brudon-Jakobowicz (13)

to previous section to next section
 

Last updated: May 3, 2013